Shareholder advances: Debt or equity?

From time to time, owners of closely held businesses might need to advance their companies money to bridge a temporary downturn or provide funds for an expansion or another major purchase

Bettye Goodwin
January 11, 2024

How should those advances be classified under U.S. Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP)? Depending on the facts and circumstances of the transaction, an advance may be reported as debt or additional paid-in capital.

What are the deciding factors?

When classifying a shareholder advance, it’s important to consider the economic substance of the transaction over its form. The accounting rules lay out the following issues to evaluate when reporting these transactions:

Intent to repay. Open-ended understandings between related parties about repayment imply that an advance is a form of equity. For example, an advance may be classified as a capital contribution if it was extended to save the business from imminent failure and no attempts at repayment have ever been made.

Terms of the advance. An advance is more likely to be treated as bona fide debt if the parties have signed a written promissory note that bears reasonable interest, has a fixed maturity date and a history of periodic loan repayments, and includes some form of collateral. However, if an advance is subordinate to bank debt and other creditors, it’s more likely to qualify as equity.

Ability to repay. This includes the company’s historic and future debt service capacity, as well as its credit standing and ability to secure other forms of financing. The stronger these factors are, the more appropriate it may be to classify the advance as debt.

Third-party reporting. Consistently treating an advance as debt (or equity) on tax returns can provide additional insight into its proper classification.

With shareholder advances, disclosures are key. Under GAAP, you’re required to describe any related-party transactions, including the magnitude and specific line items in the financial statements that are affected. Numerous related-party transactions may necessitate the use of a tabular format to make the footnotes to the financial statements more reader friendly.

Why does it matter?

The proper classification of shareholder advances is especially important when a company has unsecured bank loans or more than one shareholder. It’s also relevant for tax purposes, because advances that are classified as debt typically require imputed interest charges. However, the tax rules don’t always align with GAAP.

To further complicate matters, shareholders sometimes forgive loans or convert them to equity. Reporting these types of transactions can become complex when the fair value of the equity differs from the carrying value of the debt.

Get it right

There isn’t a one-size-fits-all solution for classifying shareholder advances. We can help you address the challenges of reporting these transactions and adequately disclose the details in your financial statements.

The Top 5 NetSuite Cloud Features to Future-Proof Your Business 

Tackle the biggest pain points for scaling your business with these top 5 scalable NetSuite Cloud features. 

7 NetSuite Issues and How to Fix Them Quickly

NetSuite is a powerful tool, but like any software, it has its own challenges. Learn how to solve the seven most common NetSuite issues. 

What is Netsuite and Why Do So Many Startups Choose It

What is NetSuite, and why do so many startups love it? There are many reasons, so keep reading to learn how NetSuite can solve your biggest pain points. 

A Must-Do Checklist for Year-Round Bookkeeping Compliance 

If you want your business to remain financially healthy, follow this monthly, quarterly, and yearly checklist for year-round bookkeeping compliance. 

5 Benefits of Using Netsuite for Financial Reporting and Analysis

You can transform your business trajectory using NetSuite for financial reporting and analysis. Keep reading to learn about the 5 benefits of using this ERP system. 

Is Netsuite Right For Your Growing Company

Every company is unique and requires different processes and workflows to reach the next stage of growth. Keep reading to learn if NetSuite is right for your growing business. 

Basic Bookkeeping vs. Advanced Financial Management: Which One Do You Need?

Does your business need basic bookkeeping or advanced financial management? Keep reading to find out. 

7 Ways a Fractional CFO Minimizes Tax Risk

Constantly changing tax laws and regulations can overwhelm a growing company. Learn these seven ways a fractional CFO minimizes tax risk.

6 Ways a Fractional CFO Can Secure Funding For Your Business

Securing funding for your business isn’t a walk in the park. It requires strategy, financial expertise, and accurate financial data to tell a compelling financial narrative. Here’s how a fractional CFO can help. 

5 Tips for a Successful NetSuite Implementation

Successful NetSuite implementation is about people, processes, and technology. Follow these five tips to drive your business forward. 

How Much Does A Fractional CFO Cost? 

How much does a fractional CFO cost? Let’s answer many founders’ most pressing questions about making this critical hire. 

How to Cut Costs, Not Corners with an Outsourced CFO

How can you cut costs for your startup without hiring a full-time CFO? A fractional CFO is the answer and here’s why. 

4 NetSuite Hacks To Optimize Your Supply Chain

To gain a competitive advantage in today’s fast-paced world, you have to stay on top of supply chain challenges. Utilize these 4 NetSuite hacks to optimize your supply chain and boost your bottom line. 

7 Common Bookkeeping Mistakes That Hurt Profitability From A Fractional CFO

Are you making these seven common bookkeeping mistakes that are hurting your profitability? Follow the tips in this blog post to protect your bottom line. 

6 Budgeting Tips for Business Success from a Fractional CFO

Read these 6 budget tips to help you define a clear financial roadmap for every decision you make as a company, and to drive a culture of financial accountability. 

Top 7 Reasons Mid-Market Leaders Choose NetSuite’s Cloud ERP

If you’re managing complex financial situations on outdated systems, it’s time to upgrade to this customized-to-fit-all solution of NetSuite’s Cloud ERP. 

When Is The Right Time To Hire A Fractional CFO

When is the right time to hire a fractional CFO? When you meet at least one of these five criteria.

The 7 Best Tax Strategies for Scaling Businesses from a Fractional CFO

As a business, you want your money working for you as efficiently as possible. Follow these 7 best tax strategies to reduce tax liability and grow your business. 

5 Financial Metrics Every CEO Should Track

If you do a Google search on important financial metrics for your business, you’ll come up with dozens of “must-have” metrics. But you only need 3-5 to succeed!

10 Ways NetSuite Helps Optimize Cash Flow and Minimize Burn Rate

Are you a founder or CEO struggling with cash flow problems and an out-of-control burn rate? Read the top 10 ways NetSuite can help solve all your biggest financial problems within a single solution.

EBITDA vs. Free Cash Flow: Which Metric Matters More?

EBITDA vs. free cash flow are two financial metrics that often find themselves head-to-head for companies between $2 million and $10 million in revenue. Which is better?

3 Signs Your Business Is In Desperate Need of a Fractional CFO

Do you have leaky cash flow problems, inaccurate forecasting, and a general lack of time or money to manage your organization’s financials? It may be time to hire a fractional CFO to save your business.

Solid financial reporting can help attract debt and equity financing

Financial reporting plays a key role when a business needs funds for continued operations and strategic investment opportunities.

Did your business buy the wrong software?

No one likes to make a mistake. This is especially true in business, where a wrong decision can cost money, time and resources. According to the results of a recent survey, one of the primary ways that many companies are committing costly foibles is buying the wrong software.

Best practices for M&A due diligence

Participating in mergers and acquisitions (M&A) offers growth opportunities for businesses, but also comes with its share of risks. It's crucial for buyers to have a thorough understanding of the strengths and weaknesses of potential partners or acquisition targets before proceeding with any deals.

Perform an operational review to see how well your business is running

In the wide, wide world of mergers and acquisitions (M&A), most business buyers conduct thorough due diligence before closing their deals. This usually involves carefully investigating the target company’s financial, legal and operational positions.

Tax-favored Qualified Small Business Corporation status could help you thrive

Opting to run your small enterprise as a Qualified Small Business Corporation (QSBC) might be a smart tax strategy.

Navigating Year-End Finances: A Real Estate Broker’s Guide to Cost-Effective CPA Solutions

As a real estate broker, you're accustomed to navigating complex deals and managing a multitude of tasks. However, when it comes to managing year-end finances, even the most seasoned brokers can find themselves in murky waters

Unleashing the Power of NetSuite: Why Your Business Needs an Expert CPA Firm

In the realm of business management, NetSuite stands out as a powerful tool designed to streamline operations and enhance financial visibility.

Financial Mastery Without Full-Time Costs: The Strategic Edge of Fractional CFOs for Tech Leaders

In the ever-evolving landscape of the tech industry, where innovation is the currency of success, financial management plays a pivotal role in shaping the trajectory of your tech firm.

New Year, New Numbers: Top 10 Accounting Priorities for a Smoother Tax Season

As the calendar flips to a new year, business owners find themselves at the threshold of a crucial period—tax season

Countdown to Tax Time: Affordable CPA Strategies for E-Commerce Success

As an e-commerce business owner using the powerful NetSuite platform, the countdown to tax time can bring both anticipation and anxiety.

Key 2024 inflation-adjusted tax parameters for small businesses and their owners

The IRS recently announced various inflation-adjusted federal income tax amounts. Here’s a rundown of the amounts that are most likely to affect small businesses and their owners.

Best practices for effective board meeting minutes

If you think the recorded minutes of your nonprofit’s board meetings are just a formality, think again

Businesses: Know who your privileged users are … and aren’t

Given the pervasiveness of technology in the business world today, most companies are sitting on treasure troves of sensitive data that could be abducted, exploited, corrupted or destroyed

Accounting for M&As

Business merger and acquisition (M&A) transactions have significant financial reporting implications. Notably, the company’s balance sheet will look markedly different than it did before the business combination.

Using QuickBooks to prepare 2024 budgets and forecasts

As year end nears, many businesses and nonprofits are planning for 2024. QuickBooks® provides budget and forecast features to help management make financial predictions, as well as assess “what if” scenarios to help make more-informed business decisions.

Tips for QuickBooks users: 5 mistakes to avoid during bank reconciliation

Reconciling bank accounts is critical to ensuring the accuracy of your company’s accounting records. The primary purpose of a bank reconciliation is to confirm that the transactions recorded in your bank statement match those shown in your accounting records.

Revitalize Sales Strategies for the Digital Marketplace

E-commerce business owners, as the year draws to a close, you and your leadership team are likely fine-tuning your vision for 2024.

Maximizing Cash Flow in Real Estate: The Power of Cost Segregation Studies

Is your real estate business fully capitalizing on the depreciation of your property investments?

Some businesses may have an easier path to financial statements

There’s no getting around the fact that accurate financial statements are imperative for every business. Publicly held companies are required to not only issue them, but also have them audited by an independent CPA

Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) for SaaS Businesses: A Comprehensive Guide

Software as a Service (SaaS) has revolutionized the software industry. The transition from traditional software licensing models to subscription-based, cloud-hosted services offers businesses scalability, flexibility, and significant cost benefits

3 types of internal benchmarking (KPI) reports for businesses

As each year winds to a close, owners of established businesses can count on having plenty of at least one thing: information.

Are you ready for year-end inventory counts?

As year end approaches, it’s time for some calendar-year businesses to perform physical inventory counts. This activity is more than a time-consuming chore; it’s an opportunity to improve your company’s operational efficiency.